Why priestly celibacy? Because Christ wanted it that way


Well, there they go again. Pope Francis spoke of celibacy, the commercial media reported it, and they got it wrong.

(Chronic failures by commercial news outlets to report happenings in the Church fully and accurately is why Our Sunday Visitor, OSV News, Catholic News Agency, America and others were founded and see themselves still today as having a mission.)

First, what did the pope say? He did not announce an end to priestly celibacy. He said that celibacy, or the choice not to marry, is not essential to the priesthood. Nobody in Church authority ever said that it was. The priesthood was established by the Lord and comes to a man in the Sacrament of Holy Orders, whether he is married or not.

Many Catholics forget that everything with which they are familiar in the Roman rite does not pertain, and has never pertained, universally or always in their Church. Millions of good, devoted Catholics worship according to the other rites of the Church, originally, because of historical developments, centered in the Middle East and Eastern Europe.

In many of these Eastern rites, priests are married. Ukraine has been much in the news. Ukrainian Catholic priests often are married and are active as priests, with the full blessings of this pope and of popes going back many centuries.

Celibacy, or the choice never to marry, is a requisite for being ordained as a priest in the Roman rite, historically based in Western Europe, and brought by Western Europeans to places like this country.

Critics of the Church, or of celibacy, say that St. Peter was married. He was. The Gospel mentions his mother-in-law (cf. Lk 4:38). Was Peter married when Christ called him to be an apostle? Was he a widower? Nobody knows. Were the other apostles married? The New Testament is silent. One guess is as good as another.

Scholars believe St. Paul was not married.

Forget Peter’s marriage. Celibacy for priests in the Roman rite, first and foremost, rests on the explicit words of Jesus. In Matthew 19, Christ said that remaining unmarried “for the sake of the kingdom” (of God) is the ideal for all Christian disciples.

St. Paul vigorously applauded celibacy (cf. 1 Cor 7). From Christianity’s earliest days, celibacy was a value. Recall the esteem for the virgin martyrs. Relatively soon came monks and nuns, who vowed never to marry.

Pope Francis addressed the hunches that, were priests allowed to marry, vocations would increase. In fact, vocations are tumbling downward in Protestant denominations in which ministers are married. The drop in vocations, for all religious groups, is another revelation of the decline overall in regard for religion.

(Some say celibacy caused clergy sex abuse. What about the similar, arguably worse, scandal among Southern Baptists, whose ministers invariably are married, usually with children?)

Modern seminaries diligently try to inform students of what they are doing when they commit themselves to celibacy. Every priest is supposed to be aware, fully, of what celibacy entails for himself, because the Church wants and expects celibacy to be desired and deliberately chosen by the priest.

The pope admitted that some change might be needed. A shortage of priests has worried Church authorities for a century. It is especially concerning in some places.

In the Diocese of Davenport, Iowa, one priest is available for every 850 Catholics. In the Archdiocese of Mobile, Alabama, it is one priest per every 800 Catholics. For the Archdiocese of Quito, in Ecuador, it is one priest for every 11,000 Catholics. In the Archdiocese of Davao, in the Philippines, it is one priest for every 14,000 Catholics.

The pope noted suggestions, nothing new, that ordaining married men as priests might help in underserved regions.

Access to the sacraments by Catholics is critical, but the Church long has insisted upon celibacy for Roman rite priests because it remembers the words of Christ, the ideal for disciples.

This article comes to you from Our Sunday Visitor courtesy of your parish or diocese.


Catholic News & Perspective

Provides information on the Church, the nation and the world from OSV, America's most popular and trusted national Catholic news source


Why priestly celibacy? Because Christ wanted it that way

Monday, March 20, 2023
By: Msgr. Owen F. Campion Well, there they go again. Pope Francis spoke of celibacy, the commercial media reported it, and they got it wrong.... Read More

Opening the Word: God looks to the heart, not outward appearances

Friday, March 17, 2023
By: Catherine Cavadini “Once when St. Catherine [of Siena] was in church, a beggar approached her, a young man — he looked as... Read More

Trusted relationships with priests key to fostering vocations, study says

Wednesday, March 15, 2023
By: Gina Christian (OSV News) — A new study cites trusted relationships with parish priests as a deciding factor in cultivating... Read More

Bob Dylan, St. Augustine and the problem of the heart

Monday, March 13, 2023
By: Kenneth Craycraft In his song, “Somedays You Write the Song,” Guy Clark wrote, “Some days you know just how it goes /... Read More

Opening the Word: The humble God humbles us

Friday, March 10, 2023
By: Father Joshua J. Whitfield Insider, out. Outsider, in. That’s what the Gospel brings about, what Mary prophesied and Jesus preached:... Read More

Dating culture crisis fuels Catholic marriage vocation collapse

Wednesday, March 8, 2023
By: OSV News OSV News) — Among Catholics, the sacrament of matrimony is in freefall. Over 50 years between 1969 and 2019,... Read More

NFL star Harrison Butker and the attraction of the Tridentine Mass

Monday, March 6, 2023
By: Msgr. Owen F. Campion Harrison Butker may not have been named the Most Valuable Player in the Super Bowl back in February, but he... Read More

Opening the Word: Following God wholeheartedly

Friday, March 3, 2023
By: Catherine Cavadini “Go forth from the land of your kinsfolk / and from your father’s house to a land that I will show you. / I... Read More

The in-between times are the most difficult

Wednesday, March 1, 2023
By: Father Patrick Briscoe From the time I was very small, I’ve always needed to know “the plan.” My mother relishes in... Read More

A bishop ‘must preach, inspire people to long for the Lord,’ cardinal tells new auxiliaries

Monday, February 27, 2023
By: Richard Szczepanowski WASHINGTON (OSV News) — Following ancient church tradition and greeted by the applause of family and friends,... Read More